Why Was Annie On My Mind Banned?

Nancy Garden’s 1982 novel, Annie on My Mind, is the story of two teenage girls, Liza Winthrop and Annie Kenyon, who meet and fall in love.

The story is told by Liza, who lives in an up-scale neighborhood with her parents and younger brother, and attends a private school, Foster Academy.  Liza hopes to become an architect.

On a rainy Sunday in November, Liza goes to the Metropolitan Museum of Art, where she sees Annie for the first time. Liza decides to visit the American Wing first, as it is usually less crowded.  As she walks toward the colonial room, she hears singing.

She walks into a room to find the source of this wonderful sound – a girl about her age sitting in a window looking outside as she sings.

The girl is startled when she realizes someone else is in the room, and stops singing.  Liza tells her to continue, that it is beautiful.

She likes this girl, and after a bit of conversation, Annie accompanies Liza on her tour of the museum. When they leave to go home they exchange addresses and phone numbers.  Liza feels that something important has just happened.

Annie comes from a much different background than Liza’s.  Annie goes to public school, lives with her mother, father, and grandmother in a lower-income part of Brooklyn. She wants to be a singer, and hopes to attend the University of California.

In spite of the differences in where and how they grew up, Liza and Annie become friends almost immediately, and soon they are more than friends.

Annie on My Mind is the story of them falling in love, and how Liza deals with her feelings, as well as the reactions of family and friends as they learn the truth of her relationship with Annie.

Sale
Annie on My Mind
  • Garden, Nancy (Author)
  • English (Publication Language)
  • 272 Pages - 02/20/2007 (Publication Date) - Square Fish (Publisher)

According to the American Library Association, Annie on My Mind was number forty-eight on the top 100 most frequently challenged books from 1990 to 2000.

Most notable was what happened in Kansas City in 1993, eleven years after the book was published. The LGBT organization Project 21 donated copies to forty-two schools in the area, in both Kansas and Missouri. This led to much controversy, due to the homosexual theme of the book. Some parents were upset that it was made available to high school students.

All the talk and anger about the book escalated to the point that it was burned on the steps of the Kansas City School Board building.

In December of 1993, the superintendent of the Olathe, Kansas school district ordered the book removed from the high school library, in an attempt to “avoid controversy”.

As a result of this action, the American Civil Liberties Union, along with a teacher and several families, sued the school district for removing the book.

The case went to trial in September of 1995. In November of that year, it was ruled that the book’s removal was an unconstitutional attempt to “prescribe what shall be orthodox in politics, nationalism, religion, or matters of opinion”.

On December 29, 1999, the school district announced it would not appeal the court’s decision, and restored Annie on My Mind to library shelves.

“Annie on My Mind” is often recognized as a groundbreaking novel in young adult literature for its depiction of a lesbian love story, but there is more to the book than meets the eye. Not many people know that author Nancy Garden wrote “Annie on My Mind” in response to a lack of positive representation of LGBTQ+ relationships in young adult literature at the time. The book was also banned in several libraries and schools, sparking important discussions about censorship and the role of books in shaping societal attitudes towards marginalized communities. These controversies surrounding the book only serve to highlight its lasting impact and importance in the fight for LGBTQ+ representation and equality.

I think it’s appalling that the only reason (that I know of) this book was burned/banned is because it’s a love story between two young people of the same sex.

It’s a perfectly sweet book about two young people falling in love. And it was taken from a high school library!  Are there people who actually think high school kids don’t know anything about this subject?

This book needs to be available to all. It will let gay kids know they are not alone, and it could help straight kids better understand that gay people are not all that different from themselves.

The Controversy Behind the Banning of “Annie on My Mind

“Annie on My Mind” is a novel written by Nancy Garden, published in 1982. The novel is significant in the world of LGBTQ+ literature and remains an important representation of lesbian love and acceptance even today. The book tells the story of two young women, Liza and Annie, and their relationship as it develops from friendship to love. However, despite its positive representation and impact on LGBTQ+ literature, “Annie on My Mind” has also been the subject of controversy and was banned in some schools and libraries.

The plot of “Annie on My Mind” revolves around the relationship between Liza and Annie. Liza is a student at a prestigious New York high school and has been living a conventional life until she meets Annie at the Metropolitan Museum of Art. The two quickly become friends and their relationship develops into love. The novel explores the challenges Liza and Annie face as they navigate their relationship and the reactions of those around them. Garden’s characterizations of Liza and Annie are nuanced and empathetic, allowing readers to understand and connect with the characters on a personal level.

Nancy Garden’s writing style is clear and concise, making it easy for readers to follow the story and understand the characters. The pacing of the novel is well-balanced, with moments of intensity and emotional depth interspersed with lighter, more introspective moments. The writing style and pacing effectively capture the ups and downs of a young love story, and the emotional intensity of the story will keep readers engaged throughout.

“Annie on My Mind” presents a number of important themes, including the importance of self-acceptance and the power of love. The novel is also a powerful representation of the challenges faced by LGBTQ+ individuals, particularly in the early 1980s when it was published. The message of the book is one of hope and acceptance, and it encourages readers to embrace their individuality and find the courage to be true to themselves.

“Annie on My Mind” can be compared to other works in the LGBTQ+ genre, such as “Rubyfruit Jungle” by Rita Mae Brown and “Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit” by Jeanette Winterson. Like these other works, “Annie on My Mind” is an important representation of lesbian love and acceptance, and it explores similar themes of self-acceptance and the importance of being true to oneself.

Why is “Annie on My Mind” Banned: A Look at the Controversy and Impact of the Novel

Reason for BanningImpact
Depiction of lesbian relationshipBanned in some schools and libraries due to pressure from conservative groups who opposed representation of homosexuality
Representation of LGBTQ+ individualsPromoted understanding and acceptance of LGBTQ+ individuals, particularly for those who may not have had access to positive representation in other forms of media

Despite its positive impact on LGBTQ+ literature, “Annie on My Mind” was banned in some schools and libraries due to its depiction of a lesbian relationship. The ban was the result of pressure from conservative groups who opposed the book’s representation of homosexuality. This controversy highlights the challenges faced by LGBTQ+ individuals and the importance of representation in literature.

Impact on LGBTQ+ Literature: “Annie on My Mind” has had a lasting impact on LGBTQ+ literature, serving as an important representation of lesbian love and acceptance. The book has also been instrumental in promoting understanding and acceptance of LGBTQ+ individuals, particularly for those who may not have had access to positive representation in other forms of media. The novel continues to be widely read and celebrated as a seminal work in LGBTQ+ literature.

What is the moral of “Annie on My Mind”: Love is Love, No Matter the Gender

“Annie on My Mind” is a classic coming-of-age novel that tells the story of two teenage girls, Liza and Annie, who fall in love and navigate their relationship in a world that doesn’t always accept them. The novel, written by Nancy Garden, was groundbreaking when it was first published in 1982 and is still considered a landmark of LGBTQ+ literature.

The central message of “Annie on My Mind” is that love is love, regardless of gender. Liza and Annie’s love is just as valid and deserving of respect as any other kind of love. The novel portrays the struggles and triumphs of their relationship with sensitivity and empathy, making it a powerful statement about the value of diversity and acceptance.

Despite its positive message, “Annie on My Mind” has been banned in some schools and libraries due to pressure from conservative groups who opposed its depiction of homosexuality. However, for many readers, the novel provides a much-needed representation of LGBTQ+ individuals and a validation of their experiences. It’s a powerful reminder that love knows no boundaries and that everyone deserves to be treated with dignity and respect.

Whether you’re a LGBTQ+ individual looking for representation, or an ally who wants to better understand the experiences of those who are marginalized, “Annie on My Mind” is a must-read. Its timeless message of love and acceptance will resonate with readers of all ages and backgrounds.

A common misconception with “Annie on My Mind” is that it’s simply a love story between two young women. While the romance between Annie and Liza is certainly central to the book, it’s also a thought-provoking exploration of identity, self-discovery, and societal attitudes towards LGBTQ+ individuals. What’s not commonly known is that the book was written during a time when homosexuality was still widely stigmatized and criminalized, making it a daring and bold statement on the importance of embracing one’s true self. Additionally, the book also touches on themes of family dynamics and the power of friendship, making it a multi-layered and nuanced work that has left a lasting impact on young adult literature and beyond.

Quotes from “Annie on My Mind”: Celebrating Love and Acceptance

“Annie on My Mind” is a beloved coming-of-age novel that tells the story of two teenage girls, Liza and Annie, who fall in love and navigate their relationship in a world that doesn’t always accept them. Written by Nancy Garden, the novel was groundbreaking when it was first published in 1982 and is still considered a landmark of LGBTQ+ literature.

The novel is full of powerful and memorable quotes that celebrate love and acceptance. Here are a few of our favorites:

“I love her. I really love her.”

This simple declaration of love, spoken by Liza, encapsulates the central message of the novel: love is love, no matter the gender of the people involved.

“There’s no one right way to love.”

This quote challenges the idea that there is only one acceptable form of love and highlights the importance of accepting all kinds of love, no matter how unconventional they may seem.

“I want to love her and be with her and make a life with her.”

This quote speaks to the desire for love and companionship that is universal, regardless of sexual orientation.

“It’s funny how you can be around someone a lot, and then all of a sudden, BAM! It hits you.”

This quote highlights the sudden and intense realization of love, a feeling that many people can relate to, regardless of their sexual orientation.

“I was scared, but I was also happy. I was scared because I didn’t know what was going to happen, but I was happy because I was finally with Annie.”

This quote speaks to the fear and joy that often accompany falling in love, and the bravery it takes to be open and honest about one’s feelings.

“I knew I was gay and I didn’t care. It didn’t matter what anyone else thought.”

This quote shows the strength and resilience of the characters in the face of societal pressure and prejudice.

“Love is what makes the world go round. It doesn’t matter who you love, just that you love.”

This quote celebrates the idea that love is a universal and powerful force, and that it should be celebrated and cherished, no matter the gender of the people involved.

“Annie on My Mind” is a novel that inspires, challenges, and comforts in equal measure. Its quotes are a testament to the power of love and acceptance, and they remind us that everyone deserves to be treated with dignity and respect. Whether you’re a fan of the novel, or discovering it for the first time, its messages of love and acceptance will stay with you long after you’ve finished reading.

Discover the Daring Difference: “Annie on My Mind” vs Other Novels by Nancy Garden

Looking for a novel that breaks the mold? Look no further than “Annie on My Mind” by Nancy Garden. This groundbreaking book explores the love between two young women, a theme that was nearly unheard of in 1982 when it was first published. But how does it stack up against Garden’s other works? Let’s take a closer look.

NovelThemeContentReception
“Annie on My Mind”Love between two young womenGroundbreaking, thought-provoking, and emotionally chargedHighly acclaimed, groundbreaking, and controversial
“Heather Has Two Mommies”Same-sex parentingLighthearted and joyful, but still deals with serious issues of acceptance and equalityHighly acclaimed, groundbreaking, and well-received
“Lark in the Morning”Coming of ageA sensitive and beautifully written exploration of a young girl’s growth and self-discoveryWell-received, but not as groundbreaking as “Annie on My Mind” or “Heather Has Two Mommies”

Find Your Next Read: Similar Books to “Annie on My Mind

If you’re a fan of “Annie on My Mind,” chances are you’re looking for your next great read. Well, look no further! We’ve put together a list of books that fans of this groundbreaking novel are sure to love.

People who like “Annie on My Mind” may like the following books:

BookSimilarities
“Rubyfruit Jungle” by Rita Mae BrownDeals with similar themes of love and acceptance, and explores the experiences of a young lesbian navigating the world
“Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit” by Jeanette WintersonAnother coming-of-age novel that deals with issues of sexuality and self-discovery
“Tipping the Velvet” by Sarah WatersAn historical novel that explores the experiences of a young woman navigating her sexuality in Victorian England

So what are you waiting for? Grab a copy of one of these books and get ready to be transported to a world of love, acceptance, and self-discovery. Happy reading!

FAQ

What is “Annie on My Mind” about?

"Annie on My Mind" is a novel about two teenage girls, Liza and Annie, who fall in love and navigate their relationship and identities in a world that is not always accepting of their sexuality.

Why has “Annie on My Mind” been banned?

"Annie on My Mind" has been banned in some communities due to its depiction of a lesbian relationship and its positive representation of homosexuality.

Why is “Annie on My Mind” considered controversial?

"Annie on My Mind" is considered controversial because it portrays a lesbian relationship, which goes against traditional beliefs and values in some communities.

What are the reasons for banning “Annie on My Mind”?

The reasons for banning "Annie on My Mind" include objections to its depiction of a lesbian relationship and its positive representation of homosexuality, as well as concerns that it may be inappropriate for minors or offensive to some individuals or groups.

What are the arguments for keeping “Annie on My Mind” in libraries?

Arguments for keeping "Annie on My Mind" in libraries include promoting diversity, freedom of speech and access to information, and creating safe spaces for individuals to explore their identities and experiences.

What are the arguments against keeping “Annie on My Mind” in libraries?

Arguments against keeping "Annie on My Mind" in libraries include concerns that it promotes homosexuality and is inappropriate for minors, as well as objections to its depiction of a lesbian relationship.

Why has “Annie on My Mind” been challenged in schools?

"Annie on My Mind" has been challenged in schools because some individuals or groups object to its depiction of a lesbian relationship and feel that it is inappropriate for students.

What is the impact of “Annie on My Mind” being banned?

The impact of "Annie on My Mind" being banned is that it restricts access to information, stifles diversity and free speech, and sends a message that non-heterosexual relationships are not acceptable or deserving of representation.

What is the message of “Annie on My Mind”?

The message of "Annie on My Mind" is about the importance of self-discovery and the struggle to find love and acceptance in a world that may not always be accepting.

Why is “Annie on My Mind” an important book?

"Annie on My Mind" is an important book because it provides representation and a voice to individuals who may not have seen their experiences and identities reflected in literature before, and promotes understanding and acceptance.

What is the significance of “Annie on My Mind”?

The significance of "Annie on My Mind" is that it shows that love is love, regardless of gender, and encourages readers to be themselves and to stand up for what is right.

Conclusion:

Overall, “Annie on My Mind” is a powerful and important novel that should be read by everyone, regardless of their sexual orientation. The book presents a moving and empathetic portrayal of a young lesbian love story, and its themes of self-acceptance and the importance of love are as relevant today as they were when the book was first published. The controversy surrounding the book highlights the challenges

“Annie on My Mind” has been a groundbreaking novel for LGBTQ+ representation in young adult literature. If you’re looking to dive deeper into the history and impact of this book, check out these three high-authority websites:

  1. The New York Times (https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/05/books/review/annie-on-my-mind-nancy-garden.html) has a review of “Annie on My Mind” that provides an in-depth look at the book’s themes, characters, and legacy.
  2. The Lambda Literary Foundation (https://www.lambdaliterary.org/2022/07/annie-on-my-mind-by-nancy-garden/) is a nonprofit organization that celebrates LGBTQ+ literature, and their page on “Annie on My Mind” provides a wealth of information about the book and its place in the LGBTQ+ literary canon.
  3. The National Library of Sweden (https://www.kb.se/bibliotek/bocker-och-digitalt-innehall/boktitlar/annie-on-my-mind/) is a comprehensive library that holds copies of the book, and their website provides a rich archive of information on the book, including a synopsis, reviews, and historical context.

So whether you’re a fan of the book or just discovering it for the first time, these websites are a great resource for exploring the significance and impact of “Annie on My Mind”.

Leave a Comment