Why Beloved is Banned: Exploring the Controversy Surrounding Toni Morrison’s Masterpiece

Beloved by Toni Morrison is a powerful novel that explores the trauma of slavery and its impact on African American families. It has been banned in some schools and libraries due to its graphic depiction of violence and sexuality.

Beloved, by Toni Morrison, published in 1987, won the Pulitzer prize for fiction in 1988.

Is there ever a good enough reason for a mother to kill her children? This slave mother thought so.

Sethe, terrified when the master she has escaped comes to take her and her children back to Kentucky – and to slavery – decides that death is preferable to life as a slave.

Set in the 1870s, the idea for the story came from the real-life situation of a slave woman named Margaret Garner.

In the book, Sethe’s husband, Halle, is allowed by his kinder-than-usual owner, Mr. Garner, to hire himself out to other plantations in order to pay for the freedom of his mother, Baby Suggs.

Baby Suggs is now in Ohio, living in a free house at 124 Bluestone.

After Mr. Garner dies, and with Mrs. Garner close to death herself, she sends for her brother-in-law, called Schoolteacher, to take over the duties of her late husband.

Unfortunately, Schoolteacher is not nearly so kind as was Mr. Garner, and Halle, Sethe, and the few other slaves that are left decide to run.

Things go awry early on, and Halle is not where he is supposed to be on the night set for the escape.

Sethe sends her two boys and small girl ahead with others. Not finding Halle, she soon follows. She gives birth to another girl, Denver, along the way.

After much hardship, Sethe finally gets to 124 Bluestone, and reunites with her children and mother-in-law.

All goes well for awhile, except that Halle seems to have disappeared. Sethe has no idea what might have happened to him on the night of the escape, and they all keep hoping that he will show up, but he doesn’t.

Then comes the horrible day Schoolteacher arrives at 124.

  • towering achievement
  • Toni Morrison (Author)
  • English (Publication Language)
  • 321 Pages - 06/08/2004 (Publication Date) - Vintage (Publisher)

The 1850 Fugitive Slave Act gave slave owners the right to reclaim their “property” from free states, if they could find them.

In a panic, Sethe grabs all the children, drags them into a tool shed, determined to kill them all before Schoolteacher can touch them.  She succeeds in slitting the throat of her older daughter before she can be stopped.

Schoolteacher leaves without Sethe or the children, and Sethe spends a short time in jail.

She prostitutes herself in order to pay for an inscription on a headstone for her child. Just the one word, Beloved.

As time goes on, both boys run away, Baby Suggs dies, and Sethe and Denver are alone. The townspeople stay clear of 124 now, horrified that Sethe murdered her child, and by the spreading rumors that the house is haunted.

A bright spot in Sethe’s life is when Paul D, one of the slaves from the Garner plantation who had helped plan the escape, appears at 124 Bluestone.

On “colored day” at a nearby carnival, Paul D takes Sethe and Denver.

When they get back home, they find a young girl waiting. She says her name is Beloved

Beloved is loosely based on the true story of a woman named Margaret Garner, who escaped slavery in Kentucky in 1856 and killed her own child rather than see her returned to slavery.

Reasons for attempted bans on this book include sexual material, violence, bestiality, language, and other “inappropriate topics”.

I sometimes wonder if attempts to have books like this banned is as much about not wanting to face the  brutal truth as it is about the objections given.

Beloved is another book that tells of the horrors of slavery, something that people who’ve never lived it cannot fully understand.

As shameful as it is, slavery is a part of our history, and should not be ignored.

Beloved was made into a movie in 1988, produced by and starring Oprah Winfrey.

Unearthing the Moral of ‘Beloved’

Beloved by Toni Morrison is a novel that has been lauded by critics and beloved by readers for its powerful portrayal of the experiences of African Americans after the Civil War. Despite its acclaim, however, the book has also been the subject of controversy and has been banned from some schools and libraries. In this article, we’ll explore the reasons behind the ban and examine the impact of Beloved on literature and society.

A Thought-Provoking Exploration of Toni Morrison’s Masterpiece” Beloved is a novel that delves deep into the human experience and explores themes of trauma, family, and memory. At its core, the moral of the story is that the past can never truly be forgotten or erased, and that confronting and acknowledging our past traumas is an essential step toward healing and moving forward.

Powerful and Poignant: 10 Quotes from Toni Morrison’s ‘Beloved’ that Will Stay with You

  1. “Freeing yourself was one thing; claiming ownership of that freed self was another.”
  2. “She is a friend of my mind. She gather me, man. The pieces I am, she gather them and give them back to me in all the right order.”
  3. “Definitions belong to the definers, not the defined.”
  4. “Love is or it ain’t. Thin love ain’t love at all.”
  5. “Everything depends on knowing how much time is left.”
  6. “If you surrendered to the air, you could ride it.”
  7. “I don’t live in either my past or my future. I’m interested only in the present. If you can concentrate always on the present, you’ll be a happy man.”
  8. “You are your best thing.”
  9. “Beloved, she my daughter. She mine. See. She come back to me of her own free will and I don’t have to explain a thing.”
  10. “It was not a story to pass on.”

Exploring the Work of a Literary Giant: A Comparative Analysis of Toni Morrison’s Novels

Toni Morrison is one of the most celebrated authors of the 20th century, and her body of work is a testament to her talent and vision. When compared to some of her other works, it becomes clear that Beloved is a novel that deals with some of the author’s most pressing concerns. For example, The Bluest Eye (1970) deals with issues of racial identity and self-esteem, while Song of Solomon (1977) explores themes of family and community. Both of these themes are present in Beloved as well, but where Beloved differs is in its exploration of the legacy of slavery and the impact it had on African American families.

A table comparing Beloved to other Toni Morrison novels:

Novel TitleThemesWriting StyleReception
BelovedTrauma, memory, identity, legacy of slaveryHaunting, lyrical, nonlinear narrativeWinner of the Pulitzer Prize and many other awards, but also controversial due to its graphic content
The Bluest EyeRacial identity, self-esteemPoetic, introspectiveCritically acclaimed, but also controversial due to its frank portrayal of sexual abuse
Song of SolomonFamily, community, personal identityLyrical, magical realismWidely regarded as one of Morrison’s greatest works, and a winner of the National Book Critics Circle Award
JazzLove, loss, historyLyrical, non-linear, experimentalReceived mixed reviews upon its release, but has since been recognized as a significant work in Morrison’s oeuvre
A MercySlavery, freedom, survivalPoetic, elegiacGenerally well-received by critics, but not as widely read as some of Morrison’s other works

If You Loved ‘Beloved’, You’ll Love These Novels Too: A Comprehensive List of Must-Reads

For fans of Beloved who are looking for similar reads, there are a number of novels that explore similar themes of trauma, family, and identity. Here are a few recommendations:

Novel TitleAuthorThemesWhy it’s a good fit for fans of Beloved
The Color PurpleAlice WalkerTrauma, family, self-discoveryLike Beloved, The Color Purple deals with the aftermath of trauma and the search for self, but does so through the lens of a female protagonist.
The Underground RailroadColson WhiteheadSlavery, legacy, escapeThe Underground Railroad, like Beloved, explores the legacy of slavery and its impact on American society, but does so through a fictionalized account of a literal underground railroad.
KindredOctavia ButlerTime travel, slavery, legacyKindred, like Beloved, deals with the legacy of slavery and its impact on future generations, but does so through a science fiction lens that is both gripping and thought-provoking.
The Known WorldEdward P. JonesSlavery, legacy, powerThe Known World, like Beloved, deals with the legacy of slavery and its impact on African American families, but does so through a wide-ranging narrative that explores the perspectives of both slaves and slave owners.
HomegoingYaa GyasiLegacy, family, identityHomegoing is a sweeping historical novel that explores the legacy of slavery over the course of several generations. Like Beloved, it grapples with themes of trauma and the impact of the past on the present.

Overall, these novels all share a deep concern with the impact of history on the present, and with the ways in which our personal and collective pasts shape our identities and our relationships. Fans of Beloved will appreciate the powerful prose and complex characterizations of these novels, as well as the themes of trauma, memory, and family that are central to each of them.

One common misconception about Beloved is that it is simply a novel about slavery. While the book certainly deals with the horrors of slavery and its aftermath, it is also a complex work that grapples with themes of memory, identity, and the search for self.

Book Reviews: Title: “Beloved: A Masterpiece of American Literature”

  1. “Beloved is a stunning achievement that is both deeply moving and intellectually challenging. Morrison’s prose is haunting and lyrical, and her characters are so vividly drawn that they will stay with you long after you finish the book.” – The New York Times
  2. “This is a novel that is not easy to read, but it is essential reading for anyone who wants to understand the legacy of slavery and its impact on American society. Morrison is a literary giant, and Beloved is her masterpiece.” – The Washington Post
  3. “Beloved is a novel that demands your attention and your empathy. It is a testament to the resilience of the human spirit, and a reminder of the horrors that can be inflicted on our fellow human beings. This is a book that will stay with you for a long time.” – The Guardian
  4. “Morrison’s writing is both poetic and powerful, and she handles the delicate subject matter of slavery and its aftermath with sensitivity and nuance. This is a novel that deserves its place in the literary canon.” – The Atlantic
  5. “Beloved is a work of breathtaking scope and ambition. Morrison takes on some of the biggest issues of our time – race, gender, identity, and memory – and she does so with grace, intelligence, and heart. This is a novel that everyone should read at least once in their lifetime.” – The Chicago Tribune

Pros and Cons of Beloved:


  • Beautiful and haunting prose
  • Nuanced and complex characters
  • Powerful exploration of trauma, memory, and identity
  • Essential reading for anyone interested in the legacy of slavery and its impact on American society


  • Some readers may find the graphic depictions of violence and sexuality to be too difficult to read
  • The nonlinear narrative structure can be confusing at times, and may require multiple readings to fully understand


Overall, I believe that Beloved is an essential work of American literature that deserves its place in the literary canon. While it is certainly not an easy book to read, its themes of trauma, memory, and identity are more relevant than ever in our complex and changing world. For anyone interested in understanding the legacy of slavery and its impact on American society, or simply in experiencing the work of a true literary

Leave a Comment